Meta Claims Downloaded Porn at Center of AI Lawsuit Was for ‘Personal Use’

Further, that alleged activity can’t moreover reliably beryllium linked to immoderate Meta employee, Meta claims.

Strike 3 “does not place immoderate of nan individuals who supposedly utilized these Meta IP addresses, allege that immoderate were employed by Meta aliases had immoderate domiciled successful AI training astatine Meta, aliases specify whether (and which) contented allegedly downloaded was utilized to train immoderate peculiar Meta model,” Meta wrote.

Meanwhile, “tens of thousands of employees,” arsenic good arsenic “innumerable contractors, visitors, and 3rd parties entree nan net astatine Meta each day,” Meta argued. So while it’s “possible 1 aliases much Meta employees” downloaded Strike 3’s contented complete nan past 7 years, “it is conscionable arsenic possible” that a “guest, aliases freeloader,” aliases “contractor, aliases vendor, aliases repair person—or immoderate operation of specified persons—was responsible for that activity,” Meta claims.

Other alleged activity included a declare that a Meta contractor was directed to download big contented astatine his father’s house, but those downloads, too, “are plainly suggestive of individual consumption,” Meta argued. That contractor worked arsenic an “automation engineer,” Meta noted, pinch nary evident ground provided for why he would beryllium expected to root AI training information successful that role. “No facts plausibly” necktie “Meta to those downloads,” Meta claims.

“The truth that nan torrenting allegedly stopped erstwhile his statement pinch Meta ended says thing astir whether nan alleged torrenting was performed pinch Meta’s knowledge aliases astatine its direction,” Meta wrote.

Meta Slams AI Training Theory arsenic “Nonsensical”

Possibly astir baffling to Meta successful Strike 3’s complaint, however, is nan declare astir nan “stealth network” of hidden IPs. This presents “yet different conundrum” that Strike 3 “fails to address,” Meta claims, writing, “why would Meta activity to ‘conceal’ definite alleged downloads of Plaintiffs’ and third-party content, but usage easy traceable Meta firm IP addresses for galore hundreds of others?”

“The evident reply is that it would not do so,” Meta claims, slamming Strike 3’s “entire AI training theory” arsenic “nonsensical and unsupported.”