The Great Tree Test: Best Artificial Christmas Trees 2025

Balsam Hill Classic Blue Spruce for $799: The Classic Blue Spruce from Balsam Hill has a nostalgic look that galore activity successful an artificial Christmas tree. However, judges agreed that it didn’t consciousness premium; Lindstrom noted it reminded her of her first-ever character arsenic a young adult. Mayer appreciated nan brownish tones successful nan needles for added realism, but felt that nan character lacked an upscale feel. The tree’s silhouette loses fullness toward nan top, and up-close inspection of nan branches and needles leaves much to beryllium desired. Despite qualms, it remains a solid, middle-grade action for those seeking a accepted look. Score: 47.5 of 75

Hykolity Artificial Christmas Tree for $130: This 1 is 1 of Amazon’s apical sellers, and has a 4.5-star mean rating, truthful we had to trial it. It mostly delivered connected expectations; judges agreed that it’d beryllium champion suited arsenic a budget-friendly action aliases successful a kids’ room. If you look closely, you tin spot nan branch wire, but judge Mayer summed it up nicely: “There’s a spot for each tree.” On nan positive side, nan needles looked beautiful realistic, and nan lights included were bully quality. One assembler noted that each ray strand needs to beryllium plugged into nan adjacent aft assembly, which was a small confusing astatine first, but different setup was beautiful straightforward, and nan value tag is inviting. Score: 46 of 75

National Tree Company Dunhill Fir (Pre-Lit) for $361: This 1 shocked everyone successful nan studio, particularly erstwhile compared to its fraternal twin, nan non-pre-lit Dunhill Fir, which classed overmuch higher. Dubbed nan “Charlie Brown Tree” by some judges and assemblers, it looked very bare moreover aft tons of fluffing. The apical branch wouldn’t beryllium upright for a prima aliases angel; cords were exposed throughout, and location were ample gaps that couldn’t rather beryllium hidden by fluffing. What looked promising successful merchandise photos didn’t construe successful person, making this 1 a disappointing prime for anyone hoping for a full, reliable tree. Score: 32 of 75