True Crime's a Popularity Contest: How Serial Killers Become Household Names (Exclusive)

Here’s a popular quiz: really galore of nan pursuing names do you recognize?

Jeffrey Dahmer, Larry Eyler, John Wayne Gacy, Ted Bundy, Ronald Domanique, Patrick Kearney, Lonnie David Franklin Jr., Charles Manson, Ed Gein.

Unless you’re a fanatical existent crime historian, I’ll stake you did not admit Larry Eyler, Ronald Domanique, Patrick Kearney aliases Lonnie David Franklin, Jr. 

And yet those 4 names correspond immoderate of nan astir prolific, horrifying serial killers successful U.S. history. Why do you instantly admit Jeffrey Dahmer, who killed 17 young men and boys, and not Ronald Domanique, who killed 21 young men and boys? Why do immoderate killers summation nationalist nickname and go a awesome of our top fears, while others quickly drift retired of nan headlines, their faces and victims mostly forgotten?

The reply is complicated. If nan media chooses to extensively screen a communicative it will summation overmuch much traction, creating lore and cementing nan killer’s notoriety successful nan nationalist mind. If a metropolis is terrorized by an progressive serial slayer for a lengthy play — New York City and “Son of Sam” David Berkowitz, Los Angeles and “Night Stalker” Richard Ramirez — memories will linger for decades, ensuring nan killer’s sanction is repeated until it hits captious mass. Sometimes a book aliases documentary will revive nan public’s fascination pinch a dormant case. And sometimes personage is nan driving factor: OJ, Sharon Tate, Robert Blake, nan Lindbergh babe kidnapping. 

But location is different logic definite killers grip nan public’s regard and ne'er fto go. And it strikes astatine nan bosom of nan modern wide fascination pinch existent crime.

Despite our technological and societal advancements, humans stay biologically wired for a different era — our primitive, ancient past. The comparative information and comfortableness of modern nine has created a caller reality successful which we expect and mostly don’t travel into interaction pinch different group intent connected murdering us. While weapon deaths — specifically wide shootings — person had devastating effects connected nine and instilled a pervasive fear, close-range, convulsive deaths by different intends stay unexpected and a distant threat. We don’t crouch and tiptoe into nan supermarket successful fearfulness of a knife-wielding madman. We don’t spell to a euphony show expecting to beryllium clubbed complete nan caput and near to die. We don’t spell to a meal statement connected defender for unit during nan dessert course.

The reality was acold different successful early quality history. Murder was a communal occurrence, for survival, for territory, for societal competition, title complete resources and sometimes conscionable because we felt for illustration it. Even wrong close, trusted groups, interpersonal unit was common. Long earlier nan improvement of courtrooms, judges and rule enforcement, reward was meted retired haphazardly wrong tribes of humans who lived pinch murder, expected murder. Over hundreds of thousands of years, we were hardwired to fearfulness not only nature, animals, illness and famine and floods, but besides different humans. It is successful our primal wiring.

And heavy wrong that panic of what others astir america are tin of, is nan knowledge that looks are deceiving. Someone who appears "normal" tin beryllium hiding a monster down nan mask, fresh to make nan translator to slayer astatine conscionable nan correct opportunity. Our primal wiring has kept america live by our communal suspicion of each other, our consciousness that immoderate humans whitethorn termination america for dominance, aliases for our nutrient aliases because they simply want to. Even nan ones who look safe. Especially nan ones who look safe. The situation has ever been, and continues to be, determining who among america hides a slayer within. It is arsenic inherent to our endurance system arsenic hunger aliases thirst.

This heavy implant of suspicion wrong our encephalon is not dormant, but modern nine has dulled it pinch nan façade of “safety.” Most of america person compartment phones that tin dial 911 instantly. There are constabulary stations blocks away, location are information guards, metallic detectors, capsicum spray, CCTV cameras, courtrooms to adjudicate superior disputes and comfortableness successful nan belief that vicious killers are acold and fewer between.

The important constituent communal to nan infamous serial killers we each cognize and grew up fearing, is nan operation of “normalcy” and horror. When nan monster appears ordinary, socialized, comfortable among different group — conscionable for illustration america — we salary attention. When we are faced pinch “a seemingly normal feline connected nan artifact who buried 20 bodies successful his crawlspace,” our primal wiring lights up, responding to that repressed fearfulness of nan group astir us, nan group we interact pinch each day, nan group we locomotion by successful our flat building, aliases beryllium adjacent to connected nan subway.

What is nan header of each wide known serial killer? Ted Bundy was a handsome, charming lawyer, but was secretly… John Wayne Gacy dressed up arsenic a comedian and entertained nan kids, but was besides … Charles Manson and his followers looked for illustration conscionable different hippie commune but past they … Rex Heuermann was an designer successful New York City and went retired drinking pinch his coworkers but successful nan basement of his suburban location … Jeffrey Dahmer was a lanky, soft-spoken nerd but successful his plain, one-bedroom flat … Every descriptor sounds nan same: nan monster lurking among us, seemingly 1 of us, but hiding thing terrible. 

Ed Gein appeared to beryllium a mild-mannered husbandman who did overseas jobs astir his Wisconsin mini municipality successful nan 1950s. Everyone knew him. He moreover visited neighbors’ homes for dinner. He was besides digging up graves, murdering section women and sewing a suit retired of quality skin. His bizarre activities shocked nan nation, but it was nan quality of normalcy mixed pinch that scary that is nan intrinsic portion of his legend. That’s what group retrieve — not only did he do unthinkable things, he appeared harmless for truthful galore years by everyone successful nan community. 

Ed Kemper murdered 8 people, including his ain mother, successful nan early 1970’s. But for decades aft his conviction, Kemper remained comparatively unknown. Then, successful 2017, nan tv bid Mindhunter premiered connected Netflix, and reintroduced nan nationalist to nan 6’9” behemoth, sending his sanction and communicative into net infamy. What fascinates truthful galore astir Kemper successful Mindhunter and successful a YouTube bid of interviews he conducted a decade aft his sidesplitting spree, is his self-awareness.

Articulate and coldly honest, he conducts a objective dissection of his ain serial killer’s mind successful work of knowing nan psychopathy of each serial killers. Kemper becomes his ain psychologist, his ain profiler, and his insights consciousness for illustration a one-time backstage walk into nan serial killer’s mind. Engrossing and eye-opening, his compelling insights laic successful unsettling opposition to nan senseless, tragic acts of execution he committed. Ed Kemper is nan embodiment of nan normal/monster duality which connects america to our astir guidelines fear.

True crime is our psychological wrestling pinch nan innate knowledge of nan quality capacity for murder. Unlike different animals, humans don’t conscionable kill. We person intent, we make civilized choices. We murder. Every clip a true crime podcast aliases documentary sends a chill down our spine, we are receiving an ancient awesome from heavy within. “Nobody suspected a thing,” nan captious statement that invades our mind, haunts our dreams and connects america to that guidelines fearfulness of nan group astir us. The much a killer’s floor plan presents some a façade we cognize and a scary we cannot statesman to understand, nan much celebrated they become. True crime fans are yet connected not to nan seizure of nan killer, nan proceedings and nan imprisonment. They are connected to nan floor plan of nan slayer themselves, nan duality of normalcy and horror. 

So, nan adjacent clip you watch a true crime documentary, download a podcast aliases publication a book that makes your tegument crawl, retrieve you’re not conscionable responding to a disturbing story. You’re connecting to thing that has been profoundly implanted successful you, a informing from your primitive ancestors to salary attraction and learn.

Never miss a communicative — motion up for PEOPLE's free regular newsletter to enactment up-to-date connected nan champion of what PEOPLE has to offer​​, from personage news to compelling quality liking stories.

Sisters successful Death: The Black Dahlia, nan Prairie Heiress, and Their Hunter by Eli Frankel is disposable now, wherever books are sold.